LLM calls

time

2026-10-01 05:24:13

pipeline

isu_pipeline

run

rus-2627-1etap_jun

step

9 people (national)

object

Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА / Александр САМОРУКОВ

model_requested

anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5

model_returned

anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5

provider

Claude Platform on AWS

latency_s

5.89

prompt_tokens

6927

completion_tokens

515

cost_usd

0.019004

finish_reason

content_filter

json_error

True

review_verdict

review_note

call_id

13206042-2a76-42ce-9cb5-5f89f52dda42

Answer

{
  "why": "invalid JSON from model",
  "decision": "unsure"
}

Task

A result row was linked to athlete card(s) by the loader, but the linkage is uncertain: several cards share the name, or the printed name matched a card only after dropping the patronymic / reordering words / transliterating. For each person on the row decide which card it is. Options: 'keep' (the current card is right), 'card' (replace the person in slot `slot` with card `card` from `alternatives`), 'new' (the person in slot `slot` is someone who has no card yet). Evidence to weigh: birth date vs the category and age step, club and region continuity, discipline and partner, score level and its progression over time, dates (one person cannot skate two events at the same time), how the name is written (a patronymic in one protocol and not in another is normal in Russian protocols; a different patronymic means a different person). Namesakes are common among children. You MUST decide; if in doubt pick the most likely option and set confidence 'low'. If several cards in the dossier (current or alternatives) look like one and the same person split across cards, list each such group in `same_person` with the card ids and your confidence; nothing is merged here, a separate review reads these groups. Put anything else that should be corrected or checked later (a wrong birth date, a suspicious career) into `followups`; you do not apply them.

Dossier

{
  "row": {
    "printed": "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА / Александр САМОРУКОВ",
    "event": "Всероссийские соревнования \"Лед Мечты\" среди юниоров, Москва, 2026-09-24",
    "category": "Парное катание - КМС",
    "discipline": "pairs",
    "age_group": "junior",
    "step": "rus_kms",
    "flag": "RUS",
    "club_or_region_printed": null,
    "place": 7,
    "total": "121.02",
    "segments": {
      "FS": "81.32",
      "SP": "39.70"
    },
    "birth_years_printed": [],
    "category_years": []
  },
  "people_on_row": [
    {
      "printed_name": "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
      "why_uncertain": "3 cards carry this exact spelling",
      "current_card": {
        "card": 8905821,
        "name": "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
        "latin": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
        "gender": "women",
        "birth_date": null,
        "results_total": 10,
        "starts_nearest_to_row": [
          {
            "date": "2026-09-07",
            "event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Cup Stage 1",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "Региональные соревнования \"Кубок Федерации\", 1 этап ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ) ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": null,
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 2,
            "total": "146.38",
            "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
            "birth_year_printed": 2010
          },
          {
            "date": "2026-02-25",
            "event": "Saint Petersburg Junior Championships",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "АНО \"СКФК Тамары Москвиной\"",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 4,
            "total": "148.57",
            "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2026-01-19",
            "event": "Grushmana Memorial",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ KMC ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ГОД), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": null,
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": null,
            "total": null,
            "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2025-11-24",
            "event": "Federation Cup",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "АНО СКФК Тамары Москвиной",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 4,
            "total": "157.68",
            "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2025-11-05",
            "event": "Russian Grand Prix – Idel",
            "level": "national_series",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "Санкт-Петербург, СК ФК Тамары Москвиной",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 6,
            "total": "136.98",
            "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2025-10-22",
            "event": "Russian Grand Prix – Magnitka Stars",
            "level": "national_series",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "Санкт-Петербург, СК ФК Тамары Москвиной",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 5,
            "total": "127.71",
            "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          }
        ],
        "first_start": "2025-01-27",
        "last_start": "2026-09-24",
        "also_in_this_category": true,
        "spellings": [
          "Darya Andreevna TRETYAKOVA",
          "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
          "Дарья Андреевна ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
          "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА"
        ],
        "birth_years_printed": {
          "2010": 1
        },
        "clubs_printed": [
          "АНО \"СКФК Тамары Москвиной\"",
          "АНО СКФК Тамары Москвиной",
          "Санкт-Петербург, СК ФК Тамары Москвиной",
          "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной / Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной",
          "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Тамары Москвиной"
        ]
      },
      "alternatives": [
        {
          "card": 9566837,
          "name": "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
          "latin": "Darya Tretyakova",
          "gender": "women",
          "birth_date": null,
          "results_total": 2,
          "starts_nearest_to_row": [
            {
              "date": "2026-01-19",
              "event": "Grushmana Memorial",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ KMC ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ГОД), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
              "discipline": "pairs",
              "age_group": "junior",
              "step": "rus_kms",
              "club": "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной",
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 4,
              "total": "162.30",
              "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
              "birth_year_printed": null
            },
            {
              "date": "2025-04-14",
              "event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Trophy",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "Парное катание КМС (юниоры, юниорки)",
              "discipline": "pairs",
              "age_group": "junior",
              "step": "rus_kms",
              "club": null,
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 2,
              "total": "158.38",
              "partner": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
              "birth_year_printed": null
            }
          ],
          "first_start": "2025-04-14",
          "last_start": "2026-01-19",
          "also_in_this_category": false,
          "spellings": [
            "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА"
          ],
          "birth_years_printed": {},
          "clubs_printed": [
            "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной"
          ]
        },
        {
          "card": 8905823,
          "name": "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
          "latin": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
          "gender": "women",
          "birth_date": null,
          "results_total": 32,
          "starts_nearest_to_row": [
            {
              "date": "2026-01-19",
              "event": "Grushmana Memorial",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "ОДИНОЧНОЕ КАТАНИЕ MC ЖЕНЩИНЫ (16 ЛЕТ И СТАРШЕ)",
              "discipline": "singles",
              "age_group": "senior",
              "step": "rus_ms",
              "club": null,
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": null,
              "total": null,
              "partner": null,
              "birth_year_printed": null
            },
            {
              "date": "2025-12-04",
              "event": "Mordovian Patterns",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "MC, Женщины (16 лет и старше)",
              "discipline": "singles",
              "age_group": "senior",
              "step": "rus_ms",
              "club": "Московская область, УОР №1, АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 2,
              "total": "186.81",
              "partner": null,
              "birth_year_printed": null
            },
            {
              "date": "2025-11-11",
              "event": "Russian Grand Prix – Golden Skate of Moscow",
              "level": "national_series",
              "category": "Женщины, МС",
              "discipline": "singles",
              "age_group": "senior",
              "step": "rus_ms",
              "club": "Московская область, УОР №1, АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 9,
              "total": "164.60",
              "partner": null,
              "birth_year_printed": null
            },
            {
              "date": "2025-10-08",
              "event": "Panin-Kolomenkin Memorial",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "MC Женщины (16 лет и старше)",
              "discipline": "singles",
              "age_group": "senior",
              "step": "rus_ms",
              "club": "Московская область, АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 12,
              "total": "154.85",
              "partner": null,
              "birth_year_printed": null
            },
            {
              "date": "2025-09-12",
              "event": "Moscow Region Junior Championships",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "MC, женщины",
              "discipline": "singles",
              "age_group": "senior",
              "step": "rus_ms",
              "club": null,
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 1,
              "total": "175.69",
              "partner": null,
              "birth_year_printed": null
            },
            {
              "date": "2025-01-27",
              "event": "Northern Waltz",
              "level": "national_other",
              "category": "Одиночное катание, МС - женщины (16 лет и старше)",
              "discipline": "singles",
              "age_group": "senior",
              "step": "rus_ms",
              "club": "Московская область, ООО \"АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
              "flag": "RUS",
              "place": 4,
              "total": "180.71",
              "partner": null,
              "birth_year_printed": null
            }
          ],
          "first_start": "2017-03-03",
          "last_start": "2026-01-19",
          "also_in_this_category": false,
          "spellings": [
            "Darya Sergeevna TRETYAKOVA",
            "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
            "Дарья Сергеевна ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
            "Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА",
            "Третьякова Дарья"
          ],
          "birth_years_printed": {
            "2007": 1
          },
          "clubs_printed": [
            "Московская область, УОР №1, АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
            "Московская область, АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
            "Московская область, ООО \"АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\"",
            "Московская область, ГБПОУ МО \"УОР №1\" / ООО Ангелы Плющенко",
            "г.о. Одинцово, АФК \"Ангелы Плющенко\""
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "printed_name": "Александр САМОРУКОВ",
      "why_uncertain": "the exact spelling is on this card only; other cards have close names",
      "current_card": {
        "card": 8925721,
        "name": "Александр САМОРУКОВ",
        "latin": "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
        "gender": "men",
        "birth_date": null,
        "results_total": 15,
        "starts_nearest_to_row": [
          {
            "date": "2026-09-07",
            "event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Cup Stage 1",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "Региональные соревнования \"Кубок Федерации\", 1 этап ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ) ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": null,
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 2,
            "total": "146.38",
            "partner": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
            "birth_year_printed": 2007
          },
          {
            "date": "2026-02-25",
            "event": "Saint Petersburg Junior Championships",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "АНО \"СКФК Тамары Москвиной\"",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 4,
            "total": "148.57",
            "partner": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2026-01-19",
            "event": "Grushmana Memorial",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ KMC ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ГОД), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 4,
            "total": "162.30",
            "partner": "Darya Tretyakova",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2026-01-19",
            "event": "Grushmana Memorial",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "ПАРНОЕ КАТАНИЕ KMC ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ГОД), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": null,
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": null,
            "total": null,
            "partner": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2025-11-24",
            "event": "Federation Cup",
            "level": "national_other",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "АНО СКФК Тамары Москвиной",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 4,
            "total": "157.68",
            "partner": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          },
          {
            "date": "2025-11-05",
            "event": "Russian Grand Prix – Idel",
            "level": "national_series",
            "category": "Парное катание, КМС",
            "discipline": "pairs",
            "age_group": "junior",
            "step": "rus_kms",
            "club": "Санкт-Петербург, СК ФК Тамары Москвиной",
            "flag": "RUS",
            "place": 6,
            "total": "136.98",
            "partner": "Darya TRETYAKOVA",
            "birth_year_printed": null
          }
        ],
        "first_start": "2017-02-17",
        "last_start": "2026-09-24",
        "also_in_this_category": true,
        "spellings": [
          "Aleksandr SAMORUKOV",
          "Aleksandr Sergeevich SAMORUKOV",
          "Александр САМОРУКОВ",
          "Александр Сергеевич САМОРУКОВ"
        ],
        "birth_years_printed": {
          "2007": 1
        },
        "clubs_printed": [
          "АНО \"СКФК Тамары Москвиной\"",
          "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной",
          "АНО СКФК Тамары Москвиной",
          "Санкт-Петербург, СК ФК Тамары Москвиной",
          "Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной / Санкт-Петербург, АНО СК ФК Т. Москвиной"
        ]
      },
      "alternatives": []
    }
  ]
}

System

You help maintain a figure skating results database. Decide strictly from the dossier. Choose only among the options given. If the evidence is insufficient, answer 'unsure'. Reply with a single JSON object: {"decision": "keep"|"card"|"new", "slot": <card id being replaced or null>, "card": <card id or null>, "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "...", "new_group": <for decision new: a short label shared by all rows of this batch that are the same new person, else null>, "same_person": [{"cards": [<id>, <id>, ...], "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "..."}], "followups": [{"card": <id>, "issue": "...", "suggestion": "..."}]} Output only the JSON object: no text before or after it, no Markdown, no code fences. Put all your reasoning into the "why" field.

Raw model text

{"decision":"keep","slot":null,"card":null,"confidence":"medium","why":"The current card 8905821 for Дарья ТРЕТЬЯКОВА is a pairs skater at the rus_kms junior step. Her partner is Aleksandr SAMORUKOV and her club is the Moskvina club in St Petersburg. She skated with him just before this event (2026-09-07 Federation Cup, 2026-02-25, and others), so partner, club and category all fit the row. Card 8925721 for Samorukov is the only exact-spelling card and has the same continuity with the same partner, so keep it. Card 8905823 is a different person: a senior MS singles skater from the Plushenko club, with patronymic Sergeevna and birth year 2007. Card 9566837 has 2 results, all in pairs with Samorukov, at the same Moskvina club. Its Grushmana Memorial 2026-01-19 result (place 4, 162.30) is also listed under Samorukov's card, and card 8905821 has a separate no-score row for the same event, so this looks like one skater split across two cards. The 2025-04-14 Federation Trophy start is likely also hers. I keep the current card, since it has the most results and the row is for the same pair. Confidence is only medium because of the duplicate cards. The birth years are inconsistent: 2010 on Tretyakova's card, and 2007 for Samorukov in the same event, so one of them is probably wrong.","new_group":null,"same_person":[{"cards":[8905821,9566837],"confidence":"high

Usage

{
  "cost": 0.019004,
  "is_byok": false,
  "cost_details": {
    "upstream_inference_cost": 0.019004,
    "upstream_inference_prompt_cost": 0.013854,
    "upstream_inference_completions_cost": 0.00515
  },
  "total_tokens": 7442,
  "prompt_tokens": 6927,
  "completion_tokens": 515,
  "prompt_tokens_details": {
    "audio_tokens": 0,
    "video_tokens": 0,
    "cached_tokens": 0,
    "cache_write_tokens": 0
  },
  "completion_tokens_details": {
    "audio_tokens": 0,
    "image_tokens": 0,
    "reasoning_tokens": 0
  }
}