- time
- 2026-10-01 05:24:51
- pipeline
- isu_pipeline
- run
- rus-2627-1etap_jun
- step
- 9 people (national)
- object
- Милана ЧЕГЕМОВА / Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ
- model_requested
- anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
- model_returned
- anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
- provider
- Claude Platform on AWS
- latency_s
- 8.28
- prompt_tokens
- 6263
- completion_tokens
- 821
- cost_usd
- 0.020736
- finish_reason
- stop
- json_error
- False
- review_verdict
- review_note
- call_id
- 7539ffa9-606d-42a5-ac41-82327ee67d5e
Answer
{
"why": "Милана ЧЕГЕМОВА has only one card (8901150), so it stays. For Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ the current card 8924676 is the better fit. It shows the same partner, Milana Chegemova, in every recent start, including the one five days earlier (Tatiana Navka Cup, 2026-09-19). The clubs are identical and the dance KMS junior level is the same, with scores around 130-152, matching this row's 132.58. Alternative card 9646106 has no starts after 2025-04-05. Its profile is the same skater: same partner, same patronymic Сергеевич, same SPb SShOR club, and a progression from 1st sport category in 2023-24 to KMS in 2025. So the two Yevgrafov cards are very likely one person split in two, and 9646106 is just an earlier fragment. Nothing indicates a namesake. The 2009 birth year on the current card fits a junior, and 2011 for Milana also fits.",
"card": null,
"slot": null,
"decision": "keep",
"followups": [
{
"card": 8924676,
"issue": "Two cards for Kirill Yevgrafov (8924676 and 9646106) appear to be the same skater. The 2023-2025 starts with Chegemova sit on the smaller card.",
"suggestion": "Have the merge review check and combine 9646106 into 8924676."
},
{
"card": 9646106,
"issue": "The Ural Gems start on 2024-02-02 lists partner Ulyana Trushnikova, while all the other starts list Chegemova. This could be a different Kirill Yevgrafov or a partner change.",
"suggestion": "Check the Ural Gems protocol before merging."
},
{
"card": 8924676,
"issue": "First start 2018-03-17 is far earlier than the partnership with Chegemova (first start 2022-10-25) and has no birth date. This may include results of another namesake.",
"suggestion": "Check the early results on this card against the 2009 birth year."
}
],
"new_group": null,
"confidence": "high",
"same_person": [
{
"why": "Same name and patronymic (Сергеевич), same partner Milana Chegemova, same SPb SShOR club, and a continuous career (1st sport category in 2023-24, KMS in April 2025). Card 9646106 ends where the current card's recent results continue. Card 8924676 starts in 2018, but its 2023-2025 starts are likely covered by 9646106.",
"cards": [
8924676,
9646106
],
"confidence": "high"
}
]
}Task
A result row was linked to athlete card(s) by the loader, but the linkage is uncertain: several cards share the name, or the printed name matched a card only after dropping the patronymic / reordering words / transliterating. For each person on the row decide which card it is. Options: 'keep' (the current card is right), 'card' (replace the person in slot `slot` with card `card` from `alternatives`), 'new' (the person in slot `slot` is someone who has no card yet). Evidence to weigh: birth date vs the category and age step, club and region continuity, discipline and partner, score level and its progression over time, dates (one person cannot skate two events at the same time), how the name is written (a patronymic in one protocol and not in another is normal in Russian protocols; a different patronymic means a different person). Namesakes are common among children. You MUST decide; if in doubt pick the most likely option and set confidence 'low'. If several cards in the dossier (current or alternatives) look like one and the same person split across cards, list each such group in `same_person` with the card ids and your confidence; nothing is merged here, a separate review reads these groups. Put anything else that should be corrected or checked later (a wrong birth date, a suspicious career) into `followups`; you do not apply them.
Dossier
{
"row": {
"printed": "Милана ЧЕГЕМОВА / Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ",
"event": "Всероссийские соревнования \"Лед Мечты\" среди юниоров, Москва, 2026-09-24",
"category": "Танцы на льду - КМС",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"flag": "RUS",
"club_or_region_printed": null,
"place": 10,
"total": "132.58",
"segments": {
"FD": "79.45",
"RD": "53.13"
},
"birth_years_printed": [],
"category_years": []
},
"people_on_row": [
{
"printed_name": "Милана ЧЕГЕМОВА",
"why_uncertain": "the exact spelling is on this card only; other cards have close names",
"current_card": {
"card": 8901150,
"name": "Милана ЧЕГЕМОВА",
"latin": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"gender": "women",
"birth_date": null,
"results_total": 45,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2026-09-19",
"event": "Tatiana Navka Cup",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Tанцы на льду, KMC, Юниоры, Юниорки",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "МО Озеро Долгое, СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР Академия фигурног",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 16,
"total": "130.64",
"partner": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-09-07",
"event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Cup Stage 1",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Региональные соревнования \"Кубок Федерации\", 1 этап ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ) ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 1,
"total": "152.66",
"partner": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"birth_year_printed": 2011
},
{
"date": "2026-04-08",
"event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду – Юниоры, Юниорки",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": null,
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 2,
"total": "147.35",
"partner": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-03-23",
"event": "Russian School Spartakiad",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 1 спортивный разряд",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "Санкт-Петербург, СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 3,
"total": "133.94",
"partner": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-02-25",
"event": "Saint Petersburg Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания на коньках\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 2,
"total": "148.21",
"partner": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-02-19",
"event": "Samarochka",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 1 разряд",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "senior",
"step": null,
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 4,
"total": "127.21",
"partner": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
}
],
"first_start": "2022-10-25",
"last_start": "2026-09-24",
"also_in_this_category": true,
"spellings": [
"Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"Milana Muratovna CHEGEMOVA",
"Милана Муратовна ЧЕГЕМОВА",
"Милана ЧЕГЕМОВА"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2011": 1
},
"clubs_printed": [
"МО Озеро Долгое, СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР Академия фигурног",
"Санкт-Петербург, СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания\"",
"СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания на коньках\"",
"СПб, ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания на коньках\"",
"Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия ФКК\" / Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия ФКК\""
]
},
"alternatives": []
},
{
"printed_name": "Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ",
"why_uncertain": "2 cards carry this exact spelling",
"current_card": {
"card": 8924676,
"name": "Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ",
"latin": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": null,
"results_total": 42,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2026-09-19",
"event": "Tatiana Navka Cup",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Tанцы на льду, KMC, Юниоры, Юниорки",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "МО Озеро Долгое, СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР Академия фигурног",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 16,
"total": "130.64",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-09-07",
"event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Cup Stage 1",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Региональные соревнования \"Кубок Федерации\", 1 этап ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ) ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ КМС, ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 1,
"total": "152.66",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": 2009
},
{
"date": "2026-04-08",
"event": "Saint Petersburg Federation Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду – Юниоры, Юниорки",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": null,
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 2,
"total": "147.35",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-03-23",
"event": "Russian School Spartakiad",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 1 спортивный разряд",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "Санкт-Петербург, СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 3,
"total": "133.94",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-02-25",
"event": "Saint Petersburg Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания на коньках\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 2,
"total": "148.21",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-02-19",
"event": "Samarochka",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 1 разряд",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "senior",
"step": null,
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 4,
"total": "127.21",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
}
],
"first_start": "2018-03-17",
"last_start": "2026-09-24",
"also_in_this_category": true,
"spellings": [
"Kirill EVGRAFOV",
"Kirill Sergeevich YEVGRAFOV",
"Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ",
"Кирилл Сергеевич ЕВГРАФОВ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2009": 1
},
"clubs_printed": [
"МО Озеро Долгое, СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР Академия фигурног",
"Санкт-Петербург, СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания\"",
"СПБ ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания на коньках\"",
"СПб, ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия фигурного катания на коньках\"",
"Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия ФКК\" / Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР \"Академия ФКК\""
]
},
"alternatives": [
{
"card": 9646106,
"name": "Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ",
"latin": "Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": null,
"results_total": 7,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2025-04-05",
"event": "All-Russian Competition",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "КМС (ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 5,
"total": "127.27",
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2024-12-02",
"event": "Klimov Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 1 спротивный",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": null,
"club": "г. Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2024-04-13",
"event": "Serebrovskiy Memorial",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "1-й спортивный разряд (Танцы на льду)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2024-04-13",
"event": "Serebrovskiy Memorial",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "MC (Танцы на льду)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "senior",
"step": "rus_ms",
"club": "Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2024-02-02",
"event": "Ural Gems",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ 2 СПОРТИВНЫЙ",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_2sport",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": "52.08",
"partner": "Ulyana TRUSHNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2023-03-21",
"event": "Southern Breeze",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ - 1 СПОРТИВНЫЙ",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "Санкт-Петербург - СПБ СШОР Фигурного",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Milana CHEGEMOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
}
],
"first_start": "2023-03-21",
"last_start": "2025-04-05",
"also_in_this_category": false,
"spellings": [
"Kirill",
"Kirill YEVGRAFOV",
"КИРИЛЛ СЕРГЕЕВИЧ ЕВГРАФОВ СПБ",
"Кирилл ЕВГРАФОВ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {},
"clubs_printed": [
"Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР",
"г. Санкт-Петербург, СПб ГБУ ДО СШОР",
"Санкт-Петербург - СПБ СШОР Фигурного"
]
}
]
}
]
}System
You help maintain a figure skating results database. Decide strictly from the dossier. Choose only among the options given. If the evidence is insufficient, answer 'unsure'. Reply with a single JSON object: {"decision": "keep"|"card"|"new", "slot": <card id being replaced or null>, "card": <card id or null>, "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "...", "new_group": <for decision new: a short label shared by all rows of this batch that are the same new person, else null>, "same_person": [{"cards": [<id>, <id>, ...], "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "..."}], "followups": [{"card": <id>, "issue": "...", "suggestion": "..."}]} Output only the JSON object: no text before or after it, no Markdown, no code fences. Put all your reasoning into the "why" field.Usage
{
"cost": 0.020736,
"is_byok": false,
"cost_details": {
"upstream_inference_cost": 0.020736,
"upstream_inference_prompt_cost": 0.012526,
"upstream_inference_completions_cost": 0.00821
},
"total_tokens": 7084,
"prompt_tokens": 6263,
"completion_tokens": 821,
"prompt_tokens_details": {
"audio_tokens": 0,
"video_tokens": 0,
"cached_tokens": 0,
"cache_write_tokens": 0
},
"completion_tokens_details": {
"audio_tokens": 0,
"image_tokens": 0,
"reasoning_tokens": 0
}
}