- time
- 2026-10-01 05:24:38
- pipeline
- isu_pipeline
- run
- rus-2627-1etap_jun
- step
- 9 people (national)
- object
- Устинья СМИРНОВА / Матвей ШИПИЛОВ
- model_requested
- anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
- model_returned
- anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
- provider
- Claude Platform on AWS
- latency_s
- 13.47
- prompt_tokens
- 5648
- completion_tokens
- 1516
- cost_usd
- 0.026456
- finish_reason
- stop
- json_error
- False
- review_verdict
- review_note
- call_id
- 7c0d69c9-ee79-48f2-a90d-38a22bfadb27
Answer
{
"why": "Shipilov: card 8925629 (born 2009) and card 9569495 look like one person split across two cards. Both carry the patronymic Вадимович, and both skate for the Moscow academy's Olimp school (МАФКК школа Олимп). Card 8925629 had Berdnikova as partner through Dec 2025. Card 9569495 appears only from Aug 2026 with Ustinya Smirnova, the partner on this row, which fits a partner change. The row's dance KMS junior step matches both cards. No evidence points to a different person, so I keep the established card with 17 results, 8925629, and flag the pair for merging. Smirnova: card 9569489 is the only exact match and is correct. It is born 2013, belongs to the same school, and has a dance history with Chelekov before 2026. Her 2026 starts with Shipilov confirm the new partnership.",
"card": null,
"slot": null,
"decision": "keep",
"followups": [
{
"card": 9569489,
"issue": "Smirnova's 2026 starts with Shipilov are linked to partner card 9569495, not 8925629.",
"suggestion": "After merging the Shipilov cards, relink the partner references."
},
{
"card": 9569495,
"issue": "A duplicate with no birth date and only 2 results.",
"suggestion": "Merge into 8925629 after review."
},
{
"card": 9708685,
"issue": "Probable misspelling of Шипилов, with a single 2015 result.",
"suggestion": "Check the protocol and merge into 8925629 if it is confirmed."
}
],
"new_group": null,
"confidence": "medium",
"same_person": [
{
"why": "Same name and patronymic Вадимович, same Olimp school, and consecutive dance partnerships (Berdnikova until Dec 2025, then Smirnova from Aug 2026). The 9569495 card has no birth date and only 2 starts.",
"cards": [
8925629,
9569495
],
"confidence": "medium"
},
{
"why": "ШИНИЛОВ looks like a typo of ШИПИЛОВ. Both are Matvey with birth year 2009, and the 2015 singles start comes just before the 2016 first start of 8925629. Nothing else supports the link.",
"cards": [
8925629,
9708685
],
"confidence": "low"
}
]
}Task
A result row was linked to athlete card(s) by the loader, but the linkage is uncertain: several cards share the name, or the printed name matched a card only after dropping the patronymic / reordering words / transliterating. For each person on the row decide which card it is. Options: 'keep' (the current card is right), 'card' (replace the person in slot `slot` with card `card` from `alternatives`), 'new' (the person in slot `slot` is someone who has no card yet). Evidence to weigh: birth date vs the category and age step, club and region continuity, discipline and partner, score level and its progression over time, dates (one person cannot skate two events at the same time), how the name is written (a patronymic in one protocol and not in another is normal in Russian protocols; a different patronymic means a different person). Namesakes are common among children. You MUST decide; if in doubt pick the most likely option and set confidence 'low'. If several cards in the dossier (current or alternatives) look like one and the same person split across cards, list each such group in `same_person` with the card ids and your confidence; nothing is merged here, a separate review reads these groups. Put anything else that should be corrected or checked later (a wrong birth date, a suspicious career) into `followups`; you do not apply them.
Dossier
{
"row": {
"printed": "Устинья СМИРНОВА / Матвей ШИПИЛОВ",
"event": "Всероссийские соревнования \"Лед Мечты\" среди юниоров, Москва, 2026-09-24",
"category": "Танцы на льду - КМС",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"flag": "RUS",
"club_or_region_printed": null,
"place": 7,
"total": "145.49",
"segments": {
"FD": "86.74",
"RD": "58.75"
},
"birth_years_printed": [],
"category_years": []
},
"people_on_row": [
{
"printed_name": "Матвей ШИПИЛОВ",
"why_uncertain": "2 cards carry this exact spelling",
"current_card": {
"card": 8925629,
"name": "Матвей ШИПИЛОВ",
"latin": "Matvey SHIPILOV",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": "2009-10-04",
"results_total": 17,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2025-12-08",
"event": "Moscow Cup Final",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Тaнцы на льду. Кaндидaт в мaстера cпoртa",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "senior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках / ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 13,
"total": "124.59",
"partner": "Vlada BERDNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-11-11",
"event": "Russian Grand Prix – Golden Skate of Moscow",
"level": "national_series",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "Москва, МАФКК - школа \"Олимп\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 9,
"total": "136.68",
"partner": "Vlada BERDNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-10-30",
"event": "Russian Grand Prix – Krasnoyarye",
"level": "national_series",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "Москва, МАФКК - школа \"Олимп\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 12,
"total": "129.18",
"partner": "Vlada BERDNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-09-01",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, KMC",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Vlada BERDNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-04-05",
"event": "All-Russian Competition",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "КМС (ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 2,
"total": "137.06",
"partner": "Vlada BERDNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-03-04",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "ПЕРВЕНСТВО МОСКВЫ ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ - KMC ЮНОШИ (11-19 ЛЕТ), ДЕВУШКИ (11-17 ЛЕТ) ЮНИОРЫ (13-21 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРКИ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": null,
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 6,
"total": "136.61",
"partner": "Vlada BERDNIKOVA",
"birth_year_printed": null
}
],
"first_start": "2016-05-18",
"last_start": "2026-09-24",
"also_in_this_category": true,
"spellings": [
"Matvei SHIPILOV",
"Matvej SHIPILOV",
"Matvey SHIPILOV",
"Matvey Vadimovich SHIPILOV",
"Матвей Вадимович ШИПИЛОВ",
"Матвей ШИПИЛОВ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2009": 1
},
"clubs_printed": [
"ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках / ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках",
"Москва, МАФКК - школа \"Олимп\"",
"ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"Московская область, МАУ \"СШОР им. Ю.Е. Ляпкина\"",
"МАУ СШОР им. Ю.Е. Ляпкина, Московская область / МАУ СШОР им. Ю.Е. Ляпкина, Московская область"
]
},
"alternatives": [
{
"card": 9708685,
"name": "Матвей ШИНИЛОВ",
"latin": "Matvey SHINILOV",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": null,
"results_total": 1,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2015-12-21",
"event": "Maryino New Year Prize",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "3-Й ЮНОШЕСКИЙ, МАЛЬЧИКИ - ДЕТАЛИЗАЦИЯ ОЦЕНОК",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_3youth",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 6,
"total": "16.70",
"partner": null,
"birth_year_printed": 2009
}
],
"first_start": "2015-12-21",
"last_start": "2015-12-21",
"also_in_this_category": false,
"spellings": [
"Матвей ШИНИЛОВ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2009": 1
},
"clubs_printed": []
},
{
"card": 9569495,
"name": "Матвей ШИПИЛОВ",
"latin": "Matvei SHIPILOV",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": null,
"results_total": 2,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2026-09-11",
"event": "Raber Memorial",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Ustinya Smirnova",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-08-24",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп, отд. Олимп",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Ustinya Smirnova",
"birth_year_printed": null
}
],
"first_start": "2026-08-24",
"last_start": "2026-09-11",
"also_in_this_category": false,
"spellings": [
"Matvei SHIPILOV",
"Matvei Vadimovich",
"Матвей Вадимович",
"Матвей ШИПИЛОВ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {},
"clubs_printed": [
"ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп",
"ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп, отд. Олимп"
]
}
]
},
{
"printed_name": "Устинья СМИРНОВА",
"why_uncertain": "the exact spelling is on this card only; other cards have close names",
"current_card": {
"card": 9569489,
"name": "Устинья СМИРНОВА",
"latin": "Ustinya Smirnova",
"gender": "women",
"birth_date": "2013-04-08",
"results_total": 31,
"starts_nearest_to_row": [
{
"date": "2026-09-11",
"event": "Raber Memorial",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Matvei SHIPILOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2026-08-24",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, КМС, Юниорки, Юниоры",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп, отд. Олимп",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Matvei SHIPILOV",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-12-14",
"event": "Angels of Plushenko Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ 1 СПОРТИВНЫЙ РАЗРЯД ЮНОШИ (11-19 ЛЕТ), ДЕВУШКИ (11-17 ЛЕТ) O1 O2 ПТ разряд рождения",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 10,
"total": "90.61",
"partner": "Andrei Chelekov",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-10-21",
"event": "Moscow Federation President Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "ТАНЦЫ НА ЛЬДУ, 1 СПOPТИВНЫЙ РАЗРЯД",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 12,
"total": "55.85",
"partner": "Andrei Chelekov",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-09-01",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 1 спортивный разряд",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_1sport",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": "Andrei Chelekov",
"birth_year_printed": null
},
{
"date": "2025-03-25",
"event": "Rublev Memorial",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Танцы на льду, 2 Спортивный BK",
"discipline": "dance",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": "rus_2sport",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 8,
"total": "67.20",
"partner": "Andrei Chelekov",
"birth_year_printed": null
}
],
"first_start": "2021-05-11",
"last_start": "2026-09-24",
"also_in_this_category": true,
"spellings": [
"Ustinya Smirnova",
"Устинья Романовна СМИРНОВА",
"Устинья СМИРНОВА"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2013": 16
},
"clubs_printed": [
"ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп",
"ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Олимп, отд. Олимп",
"ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на коньках",
"ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания"
]
},
"alternatives": []
}
]
}System
You help maintain a figure skating results database. Decide strictly from the dossier. Choose only among the options given. If the evidence is insufficient, answer 'unsure'. Reply with a single JSON object: {"decision": "keep"|"card"|"new", "slot": <card id being replaced or null>, "card": <card id or null>, "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "...", "new_group": <for decision new: a short label shared by all rows of this batch that are the same new person, else null>, "same_person": [{"cards": [<id>, <id>, ...], "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "..."}], "followups": [{"card": <id>, "issue": "...", "suggestion": "..."}]} Output only the JSON object: no text before or after it, no Markdown, no code fences. Put all your reasoning into the "why" field.Usage
{
"cost": 0.026456,
"is_byok": false,
"cost_details": {
"upstream_inference_cost": 0.026456,
"upstream_inference_prompt_cost": 0.011296,
"upstream_inference_completions_cost": 0.01516
},
"total_tokens": 7164,
"prompt_tokens": 5648,
"completion_tokens": 1516,
"prompt_tokens_details": {
"audio_tokens": 0,
"video_tokens": 0,
"cached_tokens": 0,
"cache_write_tokens": 0
},
"completion_tokens_details": {
"audio_tokens": 0,
"image_tokens": 0,
"reasoning_tokens": 772
}
}