- time
- 2026-09-30 23:32:11
- pipeline
- isu_pipeline
- run
- pilot_20260930_2331
- step
- people_llm
- object
- Алексей ЗАВОДСКИХ
- model_requested
- anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
- model_returned
- anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
- provider
- Claude Platform on AWS
- latency_s
- 5.34
- prompt_tokens
- 3629
- completion_tokens
- 464
- cost_usd
- 0.011898
- finish_reason
- stop
- json_error
- False
- review_verdict
- review_note
- call_id
- b18a13d1-142e-45ef-bd34-90a9b447da01
Answer
{
"why": "The row is a Moscow novice boys (older group) result from 2021-11-11 for the Khrustalny club. The current card 8926314 (born 2009-12-30, Moscow, Khrustalny, 65 results) fits: he would be 11 at the time, which suits a novice older-group category, and the club matches. The alternative card 9503967 (no birth date, 14 results) also has birth years printed as 2009 and the same club, and its visible starts only go back to March 2025. These two cards look like the same person split in two, but nothing in the dossier contradicts the larger, older card for a 2021 start. The alternative card's earliest shown start is 2025, so it is less likely to hold a 2021 result, although its history is truncated. I keep the current card with low confidence and flag the possible duplicate.",
"card": null,
"slot": null,
"decision": "keep",
"followups": [
{
"card": 9503967,
"issue": "Same name, same birth year 2009, same club (Khrustalny, Moscow), same KMS junior level and overlapping seasons as card 8926314. Probably one person split into two cards. The 2026-08-24 date also looks suspicious (future or mistyped).",
"suggestion": "Compare the two cards, merge them if they are the same person, and check the date of the 2026-08-24 start. Also fill in the birth date (2009-12-30) on the card if it is confirmed."
}
],
"confidence": "low"
}Task
A result row was linked to athlete card(s) by the loader, but the linkage is uncertain: several cards share the name, or the printed name matched a card only after dropping the patronymic / reordering words / transliterating. For each person on the row decide which card it is. Options: 'keep' (the current card is right), 'card' (replace the person in slot `slot` with card `card` from `alternatives`), 'new' (the person in slot `slot` is someone who has no card yet). Evidence to weigh: birth date vs the category and age step, club and region continuity, discipline and partner, score level and its progression over time, dates (one person cannot skate two events at the same time), how the name is written (a patronymic in one protocol and not in another is normal in Russian protocols; a different patronymic means a different person). Namesakes are common among children. You MUST decide; if in doubt pick the most likely option and set confidence 'low'. Put anything that should be corrected or checked later (a wrong birth date, two cards that look like one person, a suspicious career) into `followups`; you do not apply them.
Your previous answer was rejected: decision must be keep, card or new
Dossier
{
"row": {
"printed": "Алексей ЗАВОДСКИХ",
"event": "Мемориал первого чемпиона мира Сергея Волкова, , 2021-11-11",
"category": "ОДИНОЧНОЕ КАТАНИЕ МАЛЬЧИКИ, СТАРШАЯ ГРУППА",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "novice",
"step": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"club_or_region_printed": "Москва, Отд. Хрустальный (Самбо-70)",
"place": 10,
"total": "172.89",
"segments": {
"TEST": "14.96",
"SP": "56.78",
"FS": "101.15"
},
"birth_years_printed": [],
"category_years": []
},
"people_on_row": [
{
"current_card": {
"card": 8926314,
"name": "Алексей ЗАВОДСКИХ",
"latin": "Aleksey ZAVODSKIKH",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": "2009-12-30",
"results_total": 65,
"last_starts": [
{
"date": "2025-04-09",
"event": "Chernomyrdin Memorial",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "KMC ЮНОШИ, ЮНИОРЫ (11-17 ЛЕТ,13-19 ЛЕТ)",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "г. Москва, ГБУ ДО \"МАФК на коньках",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 1,
"total": "207.89",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2025-03-07",
"event": "Moscow Region Federation Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "КМС, ЮНИОРЫ",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "г. Москва, ГБУ ДО «Московская АФК, школа «Хрустальный»",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": "188.65",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2025-02-27",
"event": "Arena Play Fest Defender's Day",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "KMC, ЮНОШИ",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 1,
"total": "188.46",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2024-11-26",
"event": "Tyumen Meridian",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "KMC ЮНИОРЫ",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 6,
"total": "196.27",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2024-11-20",
"event": "Russian Grand Prix – Neva Ice",
"level": "national_series",
"category": "Юниоры, КМС",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "Москва, МАФКК - школа \"Хрустальный\"",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 11,
"total": "189.76",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2024-10-15",
"event": "Udmurtia Statehood Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "KMC - ЮНИОРЫ",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": null,
"total": null,
"partner": null
}
],
"spellings": [
"Aleksey ZAVODSKIKH",
"Алексей ЗАВОДСКИХ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2009": 41
},
"clubs_printed": [
"г. Москва, ГБУ ДО \"МАФК на коньках",
"г. Москва, ГБУ ДО «Московская АФК, школа «Хрустальный»",
"Москва, МАФКК - школа \"Хрустальный\"",
"г.Москва,ГБУ ДО \"Московская академия",
"г. Москва, ГБУ ДО МАФКК, школа \"Хрустальный\""
]
},
"alternatives": [
{
"card": 9503967,
"name": "Алексей ЗАВОДСКИХ",
"latin": "Aleksei Zavodskikh",
"gender": "men",
"birth_date": null,
"results_total": 14,
"last_starts": [
{
"date": "2026-08-24",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Одиночное катание, KMC, Юноши, Юниоры",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Хрустальный",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 8,
"total": "199.00",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2026-04-24",
"event": "Kudryavtsev Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "КМС юниоры 13-19 лет",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "Москва, ГБУ ДО МАФК Хрустальный",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 2,
"total": "189.30",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2026-03-10",
"event": "Moscow Region Federation Trophy",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "KMC, юниopы",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": null,
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 7,
"total": "173.81",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2026-02-17",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "КМС, Юноши, Юниоры",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО МАФКК, школа Хрустальный",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 12,
"total": "194.59",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2025-09-01",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "Одиночное катание, KMC, Юниоры",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": "rus_kms",
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 6,
"total": "206.98",
"partner": null
},
{
"date": "2025-03-04",
"event": "Moscow Junior Championships",
"level": "national_other",
"category": "ПЕРВЕНСТВО МОСКВЫ ОДИНОЧНОЕ КАТАНИЕ - KMC ЮНОШИ (11-17 ЛЕТ), ЮНИОРЫ (13-19 ЛЕТ)",
"discipline": "singles",
"age_group": "junior",
"step": null,
"club": "ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"flag": "RUS",
"place": 6,
"total": "216.09",
"partner": null
}
],
"spellings": [
"Aleksei Zavodskikh",
"Алексей Александрович ЗАВОДСКИХ",
"Алексей ЗАВОДСКИХ"
],
"birth_years_printed": {
"2009": 5
},
"clubs_printed": [
"ГБУ ДО МАФКК школа Хрустальный",
"Москва, ГБУ ДО МАФК Хрустальный",
"ГБУ ДО МАФКК, школа Хрустальный",
"ГБУ ДО Московская академия фигурного катания на",
"Москва, МАФКК школа \"Хрустальный\""
]
}
]
}
]
}System
You help maintain a figure skating results database. Decide strictly from the dossier. Choose only among the options given. If the evidence is insufficient, answer 'unsure'. Reply with a single JSON object: {"decision": "keep"|"card"|"new", "slot": <card id being replaced or null>, "card": <card id or null>, "confidence": "high"|"medium"|"low", "why": "...", "followups": [{"card": <id>, "issue": "...", "suggestion": "..."}]} Output only the JSON object: no text before or after it, no Markdown, no code fences. Put all your reasoning into the "why" field.Usage
{
"cost": 0.011898,
"is_byok": false,
"cost_details": {
"upstream_inference_cost": 0.011898,
"upstream_inference_prompt_cost": 0.007258,
"upstream_inference_completions_cost": 0.00464
},
"total_tokens": 4093,
"prompt_tokens": 3629,
"completion_tokens": 464,
"prompt_tokens_details": {
"audio_tokens": 0,
"video_tokens": 0,
"cached_tokens": 0,
"cache_write_tokens": 0
},
"completion_tokens_details": {
"audio_tokens": 0,
"image_tokens": 0,
"reasoning_tokens": 0
}
}